Skip to Content

Cookie Exchange Recipes: 50+ Easy and Delicious Ideas

It is Christmas cookie exchange time! If you are looking for some simple yet delicious cookie ideas you have come to the right place. I’ve collected over 50 cookie exchange recipes for you to check out.

Over 50 Cookie Exchange Recipes for the Holidays

The Christmas season is definitely the busiest time of year: buying gifts, decorating the house, visiting relatives, and holiday baking. I definitely enjoy seeing relatives, thinking of gift ideas and coming up with DIY ways to decorate the house.

Baking? I enjoy it, but this time of year seems to involve way too much time spent in the kitchen and I would rather spend time with the family.

One way give yourself more time is to get involved with a Christmas cookie exchange. How does this save you time? You only need to make one cookie recipe instead of the 5 – 10 you may usually like to have on hand.

This means less prep and clean up time is needed. Plus, you can include friends and family in the cookie swap so this counts as some holiday time with the family!

I’m not going to go into detail about how to host a cookie exchange in this post. Instead I am going to concentrate on recipes you might like to choose for your cookies this year.

If you’d like more information about hosting a cookie exchange, I have free printables and a DIY Christmas cookie exchange favor bag on my Mod Podge site. Here on DIY Candy, you can find the tutorial for making the burlap table runner I used in my cookie exchange get together.

tin of cookies for a christmas cookie exchange

Okay, lets get to the good part – Christmas cookie recipes! Since cookie exchanges don’t need to be solely about cookies, I’ve also included some alternatives such as bars, truffles, fudge, and other fun treats!

For the easy recipes that have only a few ingredients or only take a little time, I’ve included that in the description so keep an eye out for that. Go ahead now, scroll down to see the delicious recipes I’ve collected for you.

Cookie Exchange Recipes

Looking for something to make for your cookie exchange or swap? Here are 50+ recipes including cookies, truffles, bars, fudge and other treats. Many have only a few ingredients or take very little time. Take a look at my go-to cookie exchange recipes.

Cookies

Bars

Truffles

Fudge

Treats


What cookie exchange recipe will you be making this year? Did I leave your favorite off of the list? Let me know in the comments below. I’d also love for you to visit the following posts:

Joss

Thursday 2nd of December 2021

What a fun post! So many good treats on this list. Bookmarked.

Amy

Thursday 2nd of December 2021

Thank you so much Joss!