Skip to Content

20 Yummy Cookie Exchange Recipes You’ll Drool Over

Need some cookie exchange recipes for an upcoming gathering? Here are 20 delicious and tasty cookies to choose from – pick your favorite!

Need some cookie exchange recipes for an upcoming gathering? Here are 20 delicious and tasty cookies to choose from - pick your favorite!It was sort of a mistake to do this post. Because starting it I was hungry, and then I only got hungrier as I stared at the amazing pictures of the most delicious cookies in the universe. I want to try them all! Have you ever been to a cookie exchange? My mom and I went to one once, and I didn’t expect a lot – I thought we’d get to sample a few different types. We left with a whole boatload of yummy treats that lasted for months! If you’ve never been, I encourage you to find one and go as soon as possible . . . and here are 20 cookie exchange recipes to choose from. Any one of these would cause people to squeal in delight, so scroll through these cookie exchange recipes and pick your favorite.

(go here for more easy cookie recipes!)

Cookie Exchange Recipes

Need some cookie exchange recipes for an upcoming gathering? Here are 20 delicious and tasty cookies to choose from - pick your favorite!

Cherry Limeade

If you’re looking for something a bit different, these frosted cherry lime shortbread cookies fit the bill (and they are in Christmas colors!).

Get the recipe at Baking With Blondie

Need some cookie exchange recipes for an upcoming gathering? Here are 20 delicious and tasty cookies to choose from - pick your favorite!

Raspberry Spritzer

Mandy took a standard spritzer cookie up a notch by adding the raspberry as well as almond creme filling.

Get the recipe at Baking with Blondie

Need some cookie exchange recipes for an upcoming gathering? Here are 20 delicious and tasty cookies to choose from - pick your favorite!

Sandwich Cookies

I love the design pressed into these yummy little cookies, made with peanut butter and a marshmallow filling.

Get the recipe at Baking with Blondie

Need some cookie exchange recipes for an upcoming gathering? Here are 20 delicious and tasty cookies to choose from - pick your favorite!

Peppermint Candies

These bite sized sugar cookies are frosted and wrapped to look just like peppermints. This is one of the cutest cookie exchange recipes ever!

Get the recipe at Bakerella

Need some cookie exchange recipes for an upcoming gathering? Here are 20 delicious and tasty cookies to choose from - pick your favorite!

Chocolate Truffle & Sea Salt

I love how sea salt enhances the delicious flavor of these melt-in-your-mouth chocolate cookies.

Get the recipe at All Recipes

Need some cookie exchange recipes for an upcoming gathering? Here are 20 delicious and tasty cookies to choose from - pick your favorite!

Andes Mint Grinch

I love getting Andes Mints as an after dinner treat! They are even better when added to green sugar cookies.

Get the recipe at Six Sisters’ Stuff

Need some cookie exchange recipes for an upcoming gathering? Here are 20 delicious and tasty cookies to choose from - pick your favorite!

Cherry Snowballs

Filled with cherry and covered in coconut, I’m wondering how many I can put in my mouth at the same time.

Get the recipe at Chef in Training

These delicious peppermint pudding cookies are loaded with yummy chocolate and would be perfect for a cookie exchange or bake sale!Chocolate, buttercream frosting, and crushed peppermint on top – need I say more?

Chocolate peppermint pudding cookies here at DIY Candy

Need some cookie exchange recipes for an upcoming gathering? Here are 20 delicious and tasty cookies to choose from - pick your favorite!

Soft Gingersnap

Any sort of soft cookie is great by me, especially when you and ginger and white chocolate.

Get the recipe at Two Peas and Their Pod

Need some cookie exchange recipes for an upcoming gathering? Here are 20 delicious and tasty cookies to choose from - pick your favorite!

Dark Chocolate

Rosie improved upon a standard sugar cookie by making it chocolate – and dark, at that.

Get the recipe at Sweetapolita

Need some cookie exchange recipes for an upcoming gathering? Here are 20 delicious and tasty cookies to choose from - pick your favorite!

Reindeer Cookies

Rosie made her gingerbread cookies perfect for exchanging by turning them into beautiful reindeer.

Get the recipe at Sweetapolita

Need some cookie exchange recipes for an upcoming gathering? Here are 20 delicious and tasty cookies to choose from - pick your favorite!

Salted Caramel

Amy combined brown butter sugar cookies with her favorite Hershey Kisses for this delicious treat.

Get the recipe at Chew Out Loud

Need some cookie exchange recipes for an upcoming gathering? Here are 20 delicious and tasty cookies to choose from - pick your favorite!

Glitter Cookies

Add edible glitter crystals and pink pearl dust to really make these cookies holiday ready.

Get the recipe at The Frugal Girls

Need some cookie exchange recipes for an upcoming gathering? Here are 20 delicious and tasty cookies to choose from - pick your favorite!

Oreo Truffle

These chewy chocolate cookies are made even more fabulous with a mint truffle center.

Get the recipe at Made to be a Momma

Need some cookie exchange recipes for an upcoming gathering? Here are 20 delicious and tasty cookies to choose from - pick your favorite!

Peppermint Snickerdoodles

Spice up a regular snickerdoodle cookie with a taste of something minty.

Get the recipe at Taste and Tell

Need some cookie exchange recipes for an upcoming gathering? Here are 20 delicious and tasty cookies to choose from - pick your favorite!

Pretzel Treats

You only need three ingredients and a few minutes to make these.

Get the recipe at The Frugal Girls

Need some cookie exchange recipes for an upcoming gathering? Here are 20 delicious and tasty cookies to choose from - pick your favorite!

Red Velvet Cheesecake

These delicious cookies take standard red velvet and improve on them with a decadent cheesecake filling.

Get the recipe at Two Peas & Their Pod

Need some cookie exchange recipes for an upcoming gathering? Here are 20 delicious and tasty cookies to choose from - pick your favorite!

Eggnog Cookies

Cassity turned one of the most well-known flavors of the season into a delicious cookie with frosting.

Get the recipe at Remodelaholic

Need some cookie exchange recipes for an upcoming gathering? Here are 20 delicious and tasty cookies to choose from - pick your favorite!

Cranberry Bliss Bars

This copycat of Starbucks famous treat is just as delicious as the original.

Get the recipe at Remodelholic

Need some cookie exchange recipes for an upcoming gathering? Here are 20 delicious and tasty cookies to choose from - pick your favorite!

Thumbprint Cookies

I’ve always loved these cookies, but never had them with strawberry or apricot jelly like they were made with here. They look amazing!

Get the recipe at The Frugal Girls

Need some cookie exchange recipes for an upcoming gathering? Here are 20 delicious and tasty cookies to choose from - pick your favorite!

Walnut Brownie

Taste just like your standard (delicious) brownie, but made in cookie form.

Get the recipe at The Frugal Girls

These cranberry-walnut cookies with white chocolate chips are the perfect combination of tart, sweet, and crunchy. This is my FAVORITE cookie recipe for cooler weather!
Previous
Cranberry-Walnut Cookies with White Chocolate Chips
Next
Crafting Surfaces You Should ALWAYS Get Online